I'm very split about this film... and I'm quite amazed that the vast majority of people are really bigging it up.
First, the positives:
1. The 'Transformers'. Felt that they all worked really well, not too concerned that Bumblebee wasnt a VW - thought he was pretty cool. Prime was cool, even Megatron, and i thought he looked naff prior to seeing the film.
2. Concept of having Megatron in storage was relatively cool.
3. Tranforming wasnt as bad as I imagined it would be.
4. Initial sequence at the airbase was cool.
Negatives:
1. Where were the battles... We saw Bumblebee commence a fight with Barricade, but the it then switched to a battle between a ridiculously fast and blurred! robot fighting with Sam and Mikaela. And please dont say he was like that cause his name was Frenzy!! Suddenly, we see Bumblebee recovering from fight, and Barricade lying there looking sullen!?
2. How did a quiet little 'eastern' village hold off Scorponok for so damn long. Blackout near to knocked out an airbase in seconRAB, whereas Scorponok got a real battle!!!
3. Sector Seven - cool idea, but why were they a bunch of goons? Where was the need for Sam to be able to strip em down - purely for comedy?? Is this really a children's film - see point 3a!
3a. Children film right!? Then where does the mention of masturbation come into a childrens film? Im astonished that this got in there, when Spielberg was involved!? It wasnt humours - it was bad taste in my mind.
4. Autobots acting like idiots in the garden!? Would they give a damn about the garden. Would they be tip-toeing, and saying "oops".. "let me kill the animals"????
5. Like someone's said above, the army seemed to have more impact that the Autobots... Where were the massive battles, where humans could do nothing but look on? Bay just seemed to have transformers flying through the air, somersaulting, hitting the ground, and stuff, whilst the army did the battle, sliding beneath robots, and blowing 'em up!?
6. Where was Starscream!! Got SO little screen-time!!
7. Jon Voight running!!! Please no, leave that to your daughter Jon!
8. Why didnt Prime take the cube, and get it away from the City!! Why did the Army need to be involved, when Starscream et al could've taken them out in seconRAB.
That's a few of my points. Overall, I'd say maybe 5/10 Could have down so much better.
In my mind, remove some of the filler sequences - Masturbation, Finding the glasses/autobots destroy the garden, parents, etc... and replace with decent character building on the film's characters!!