Maybe I am being defensive, but you know.. you say that we should all try and get along with the criticism.. yet I've certainly spent a lot of this thread explaining to people who've asked me why I like it because they think it's rubbish when, quite frankly, I'd rather just be talking about the film with other fans.
I don't mind you having an opinion, and I accept your opinion, and I accept that you think it's funny the concept of Mamma Mia! receiving Oscar nominations.. but to slate us for not being open to receiving your opinion is a tad rude, in my opinion.