Unsatisfactory and Unresolved loose-ends in Revenge Of The Sith

You do know that Darth Sidious and Palpatine were one in the same person?

Sidious was Dooku's master. So if Dooku knows about the Clone Army surely Sidious/Palpatine knows about it too?

The
 
did i miss something because in ROTJ i think it was leia said that her mother died when she was very young but for those who watched ROTS you can guess what i am going to say. next point leia is a pricess, but doesn't she get adopted by a space captain or something simmilar.
 
1) I know they lived together, but the whole marriage to Padme was against the jedi code, yet the council seemingly chose to ignore it. Similarly, when Anakin slaughtered the sand people Yoda felt his suffering and anger, yet again the council chose to ignore it. They knew that these feelings lead to the dark side, yet they did nothing to change this. Excluding him from the council increased Anakins frustrations again leading him down the dark path. I thought the council acted very niavely.

2) Didn't Vader go to Tattooine in A new hope? I know he did not know that Luke and Leia survived, but I would have thought that one who was so strong in the force would have been able to detect the presence of his own flesh and blood no matter where they were?
 
At the end of Revenge of the Sith, what really became the fate of the wookies?

How many survived the turnaround of the clone army? How did Chewie survive to make it to Episode 1V all those years in the future?

More explanation from Lucas we did not get.
 
You are all of course missing the biggest flaw of this film.

It's a steaming dog turd that should have never been committed to celluloid. Then again so are the other 5 films.

It has been my misfortune to sit through all of these and I really cannot understand why they are loved by so many. The dialogue is stilted, the story is flawed and the acting is laughable. As overrated as Lord Of The Rings is (and before you defenders start, I'm not starting a debate) at least they make the effort.
 
You do know that Darth Sidious and Palpatine were one in the same person?

Sidious was Dooku's master. So if Dooku knows about the Clone Army surely Sidious/Palpatine knows about it too?

Like I said, this was all part of the master plan to create the Empire.
 
To answer Evilsam, Vader never went to tattoine in ANH, Storm Troopers were there but Vader was tucked up in bed on the rebel blockade runner.

To be fair if that gunner at the start had of just done his job and destroyed the escape pod 3PO and D2 were on all this trouble with the downfall of the empire could have been avoided.

It's all good anyway, the only snag I had was that Anakin was the one to bring balance to the force... which he does in Jedi when he kills Palpatine.

Works for me.
 
suckadelic used to have a webpage on this, he was out with his hoes the night before in his illest pimpin' gear and thus was not on his game

pity that website has gone, the sight of someone in a boba fett outfit with a record deck on his back will live with me forever... the breakdancing stormtroopers are still online though
 
Oh I came here to ask that exact same question. Watched and love Sith, saw it last night. Got home and watched New Hope.

It just didnt seem tio fit together. Uncle Owen talks as if he knew Anikin well, was Darth always planned to be the father?

C3PO also didnt know Obi Wan, he had no recollection who he was when asked by Luke. But there is was in Sith with Obi Wan.

I forgave it terms of so much time has passed but it seems odd to think that this well respected legendary Jedi was forgotten by 3P0. Although I can appreciate Ben not remembering them
 
afew other loose enRAB..

according to the DB over at starwars.com Darth Vader challengers Obi-Wan to a duel which he looses.. this is wrong

it still says Obi-Wan was trained by Yoda and not Qui-Jon Jin as well

once Vader knows Padme is dead why does he stay with the dark side.. he only went over to save her.. once she ws dead he could go back.. the lines in the 4-6 about you don't know the power of the dark side aren't really explained

Vader is known as the Dark Lord of the Sith.. even in the book GL wrote.. but he is only the apprentice surely Palpatine would be the Dark Lord
 
I don't know about this clone army business, but did anyone else think that for a galactic empire it took them an awful long time building that Death Star? They've made a good start on it by the end of Ep. 3. Fast forward 17 years or so and they're still not much further on. Christ on a bike, who's building it? The Wembley Stadium contractors?
 
If you've seen Episdoe III, you may not have noticed that Senator Organa gave orders for C-3PO's memory to be erased at the end of the film.

That's why he didn't recognise Obi-Wan-Kenobi.
 
You got to think though that in Anakin's mind, it is a fact that Padme is going to die in childbirth, and he is complete despair over it. She's the reason he keeps on living. His heart and soul. He's given a way to save her. He takes it. He is already at the fear stage at that point. Fear of losing Padme. :)
 
There was a little evidence, but after all, it is all subjective.



Organa had C-3PO's memory wiped in Revenge, very near the end. That's why he doesn't remember him.

JC

Edit: Oops, you beat me to that one there ccaaeac
 
see my other post above.. after he finRAB out she is dead why doesn't he then go back.. he'd only been dark side for a few days.. why didn't he vent his anger at Palpatine for not giving him the power to save her
 
On starwars.com databank for Leia it says:
"It was common knowledge throughout the court that Leia was adopted into the Royal Family."

Therefore I think she was definitely remembering her REAL mother i.e. Padme - either through photographs or through Force imagery / mother daughter connection.
 
Back
Top