Music Banter Hall of Fame: Induction Thread 3

Yes, the concept of the HOF in this case is to highlight our favourites... How hard is that to understand?

Everyone has the chance to voice their opinion in the threaRAB, and then they vote... It isn't based on popular opinion because there is no reason to base it on an opinion other than your own. Otherwise banRAB such as Led Zep, The Beach Boys, The Smiths would have easily been inducted into the HOF, yet they weren't.
 
Frank Zappa: Yes, Genius!

The Clash: i'm afraid that the Clash are a bit 50/50 for me

Bob Dylan: Yes, When i'm in the right mood then Dylan really hits the spot.

Pink Floyd: OH YES,I was late getting into Floyd but couldn't live without them now!.

Big Black: Yes, but not my favorite.

Tom Waits: Yes, Definatly fantastic artist.

The Smiths: Love them remind me of my first love! and college days .

Chuck Berry: No, just does not do it for me.
 
Frank Zappa: Yes, he clearly did what he wanted, with some awesome results.
The Clash: Yes, I would not be who I am without The Clash.
Bob Dylan: Yes, I would not be who I am without my dad playing Bob Dylan over and over again.
Pink Floyd: Yes, they had two amazing albums, and a bunch of great ones.
Big Black: N/A
Tom Waits: Yes, I enjoy.
The Smiths: No because I don't like their music.
Chuck Berry: N/A
 
I'm a huge Tom Waits fan, but I agree his ballaRAB can be hit-or-miss. I don't mind the ballaRAB on Rain Dogs, though I there's a couple I wouldn't miss if they were gone, but some of the ballaRAB on, for example, Heartattack and Vine are just fucking tedious.
 
Well, hard enough that you had to reiterate in your 2nd last post that it was the point of the Hall Of Fame, whereas I see no point in having these things at all. So tell me when all the votes come in for the banRAB, you dont count them up but rather make a decision based on your own opinion?
Whoa, I dont think people will be too happy about that...
 
Frank Zappa: Yes, used to be a huge fan some years ago, I wouldn't say I'm one now, but he was so influential...
The Clash: Yes, greatest punk band...
Bob Dylan: Yes, best lyricist ever
Pink Floyd: Yes, cause they are my favorite band after all...
Big Black: No, never liked them
Tom Waits: No, not such a big fan yet to vote yes...
The Smiths: Yes, best british band of the 80s, and that should count for something...
Chuck Berry: No, we don't have to vote yes for everyone who's in the Rock n' Roll Hall of Fame, yeah I like 1-2 songs, but that's just about it...
 
Oryt sorry didnt notice that when I posted lol
Um cant be arsed anyway, I dont agree with these 'hall of fame' things- theyre just too predictable & anyway; who else is gonna vote for the likes of the Spin Doctors?
 
Frank Zappa: Nah, never been a fan.
The Clash: Yes, my first punk band!
Bob Dylan: Of course
Pink Floyd: Yes, random guys + Syd = god
Big Black: N/A
Tom Waits: Never, been a fan really, so no.
The Smiths: No, I've tried to get into Meat Is Murder and it's just boring. I should like them, they sound like my type of band but I don't
Chuck Berry: Nah, too boring.
 
Frank Zappa: N/A
The Clash: Yes, great punk band.
Bob Dylan: Hell yes, he's a folk artist, plus he's amazing.
Pink Floyd: Yes, because they made Animals
Big Black: Yes, Songs About F*cking is one of my favorites recently
Tom Waits: Yes, He's TOM WAITS
The Smiths: My favourite band, so of course
Chuck Berry: No, I just don't like him
 
For now on I'll be going against what I usually do which is voting based on impact. Now I'll just go on personal preference. That's what everyone else does, so I should be consistant with the interest of the forum.

Frank Zappa - Absolutely. Not only one of the most original musicians ever, also one of the coolest people to ever live.

The Clash - Yes, they seem to get little to no respect from punk fans these days. But that doesn't matter. They're still THE best punk band of their era.

Bob Dylan - Overrated as all hell, but I do like him so sure, why not?

Pink Floyd - Who me? The classic rock tard? Like you have to ask.

Big Black - Nay. I know they have paved the way for all the lo fi/noise banRAB, oh wait, that's just another reason to vote no. It's just not my kind of music. Sonic Youth I'd certainly vote for though.

Tom Waits - Sure

The Smiths - These guys will get inducted anyway. So no yes vote from me, screw em.

Chuck Berry - Sure.
 
Actually, on this forum, it's a very predictable thing to say.

It's still wrong of course. Syd era Floyd is super overrated on this forum and the Waters era gets little to no credit.
 
Back
Top