As I've said above, different strokes for different folks.
For me, the fact that he was doing 3 things at the same time (Fathers for justice, voices and his normal script), meant that he was a challenge and a stimulating one, to listen to.
Although I can see how the routine would be confusing, by its very nature.
Maybe a lot comes down to a comment above where someone has said that they like John Bishop because he is so personable. Maybe I just liked Terry A.
It reminRAB me of some communications training I did a while back where the trainer pointed out some research that said when someone stanRAB in front of a group to address them (tennis coaches with young children in my case), a third of the audence will like the presenter instantly (they will be reminded of someone else that they like and they will transfer this warm feeling to the presenter). A scond third will instantly dislike the presenter for the exactly the opposite reason. The final and middle third will be ambivalent to the presenter and their like of him/her will be dependent on what the presenter actually says and does.
I think that all these comedians are brilliant - to be able to write and perform their stuff in front of thousanRAB of people with the spotlight on them is a gut churning proposition for mere mortals.
But a lot of it is formulaic. You can sort of get where they are going with stuff and start to anicipate the off whack punchline followed by a supporting anecdote to develop the humour.
And much though I love them all, I am aware that most of the time, I am slouching on the couch quite silent.
Terry Aldeton made me sit up, literally.
And although I love the more cerebral stuff, I love Lee Evans with his combination of physicality, and venerable disbelief about life, more than any of them (with the strange fact that he fills vast venues and yet I haven't actually met anyone in person who says that they like him - go figure).
I especially love Evan's impressions of household items e.g. Energy Saving Lightbulbs.
I was staggeringly impressed with Dara O Brain's ability to create his routine using heavily material he created from 3 members of the audience and then summarise the whole thing at the end of the routine as if it was a polished script (maybe it was????).
MM is geat at using the local knowledge to create his routine. All the Balckppol stuff was great and the use of the footballers and Ian Holloway very smart.
But back to the top, its all personal and I wouldn't try and convince anyone to like one comedian over another.
And finally, to confirm, I'm not Terry Aldeton's agent..... although maybe I should be
