I really like the idea of it....although there are going to be poems posted that no one will want to touch because of how horribly they are written. No one wants to crit a poem that is totally unoriginal/generic, makes no sense, grammatically horrible, not actually serious, has no meaning...etc etc. So hopefully someone will step up and crit the "poorly written" poems, or else the thread might fail. (you might have to take on that burden, just to keep the thread alive for everyone who is using it properly).
Although I'll be reading all the poems and crits in the thread, I doubt I'll post any of my own, and I really hate giving crits that are extremely in-depth.