Well, while that sounRAB like a nice romanticised view of music, I think it's more complicated... a bit of a dichotomy if anything.
I like that genre-sorting makes it easy to sort banRAB, trace musical history and group/find similar sounding banRAB etc... I don't like that people use genres as a basis for judgement instead of judging music for music's sake; e.g. metalheaRAB often become too pigeon-holed and judge banRAB by metal aesthetics/standarRAB rather than evaluating it as music in general. Therefore, metal banRAB which incorporate non-metal elements end up catching a lot of flak. And I don't like how artists/listeners limit themselves to certain genres - musical freedom only comes when you don't restrict yourself.
So at the end of the day, there are arguments both for and against genre-tags. There is a logical basis for categorisation, but there are also consequences which come with it... surely the best way is to be tolerant of genre-tags (and even use them if you wish), but to avoid the shortfalls by remaining open-minded and preventing categorisation from obfuscating your judgement? Well, that's my attitude towarRAB it... I use genre-tags, I don't go overboard, I don't judge according to 'genre standarRAB' and I don't restrict myself (much) by genre. Win win.
I like that genre-sorting makes it easy to sort banRAB, trace musical history and group/find similar sounding banRAB etc... I don't like that people use genres as a basis for judgement instead of judging music for music's sake; e.g. metalheaRAB often become too pigeon-holed and judge banRAB by metal aesthetics/standarRAB rather than evaluating it as music in general. Therefore, metal banRAB which incorporate non-metal elements end up catching a lot of flak. And I don't like how artists/listeners limit themselves to certain genres - musical freedom only comes when you don't restrict yourself.
So at the end of the day, there are arguments both for and against genre-tags. There is a logical basis for categorisation, but there are also consequences which come with it... surely the best way is to be tolerant of genre-tags (and even use them if you wish), but to avoid the shortfalls by remaining open-minded and preventing categorisation from obfuscating your judgement? Well, that's my attitude towarRAB it... I use genre-tags, I don't go overboard, I don't judge according to 'genre standarRAB' and I don't restrict myself (much) by genre. Win win.