Wall-E - the best movie robot ever?

It's a great movie...... I haven't watched all robot movies...... So I can't judge. But deffo the best of the year so far. Until TDK of course ;)
 
Impossible, a shoddy CGI rip off of Johnny 5 can not be better than him.

Thats sacrilege. You should be banned from the forums for making such an outrageous statement. ;)

Heck the wall-e guys even ripped off the part in short circuit when johnny 5 accidentally runs over an insect.
 
well its gonna split its audience this film is

its like a computer animated 2001/2010 space odyssey

you will either love it, it is different

or hate it, for no substance
 
The first thing I thought when I saw the big cardboard Wall-E at my local Vue about four months ago was "That's just a short fat version of Johnny 5!"

Of course everything I've heard and read about Wall-E suggests it's a masterpiece, which is a lot more than you can say about Short Circuit (no matter what I thought when I was 7).

Not sure you can say he's already more of a legend than R2D2 though, or C3P0, no matter how good this film is.
 
Haven't seen Wall-E yet but looking at the design...yeah, he owes a lot to Johnny 5 and perhaps a nod to the robots from Silent Running as well.

Still, critics are falling over themselves to give this movie rave reviews, so maybe Wall-E is the best movie robot ever...even if just an animated one
 
According to the poster below it's a clear rip-off of Johnny 5 so I'd go with the Short Circuit storyline :p



Pity it's got nothing to do with Short Circuit apart from the slight likeness when it comes to robot design.
 
Back
Top