Toonzone Top 25 manga nominations

If I had known there was going to be an manga and anime list, I would of picked different anime series as my main choices. Some to fair are better in anime form like BECK, YYH and Excel Saga but Detective Conan and Kinnikuman (Not Ultimate Muscle) work much better as manga series.

1 - One Piece - The manga is even better than the anime so of course it retains my nuraber 1 top spot.
2 - Ouran High School Host Club - The anime was great but the manga is still continuing and as said before, the changes work in its favour.
3 - Death Note - This is one of my favourite manga series and the anime rushed the second half/ending, making the manga the clear winner.
4 - Detective Conan
5 - Dragon Ball - the anime, espically Z, dragged out alot of the series but I find the original 42 volume series quite enjoyable. A great read.
6 - Shaman King - A series which is much more enjoyable and less kiddified in its original form.
7 - Ruruoni Kenshin - I haven't read alot of the manga but I enjoyed what I read and since i've heard the manga was more complete (and contains a skull on a canonball draw by a certain future pirate artist), it neeRAB to be placed on here.
8 - Uresei Yatsura - The original (and best) epic by Rumiko Takahashi
9 - Pretty Face
10 - Kinnikuman

I would have liked to include Yu Yu Hakusho but the anime is much better so i'll leave it off this time around.
 
Oh man, some of Togashi's art in Hunter x Hunter looks like a kid couldve drawn it, and its not just that hes a poor artist, hes also a very lazy artist.

I got to agree with, this manga is a like a masterpiece, lol (such a fanboy i am).
 
Hey, Desensitized, I didn't know that you liked Bakuman as well.

I think that its a great manga, and it shows that the author of Death Note can do really diverse genres of manga, rather than just being a "one-trick pony," being that this series is very different in how its light-hearted and also very humorous at times, as opposed to Death Note which is mostly very dark and serious. However, I still personally prefer Death Note as the author's better work, mainly due to the characters. With Bakuman, while most of the characters are fun and likeable, none of them have really stood out to me too much, wehreas with Death Note, we have the ultimate "cat and mouse" duo really early on in the story (of course that kind of gets lost about half-way into the story, but there are still interesting characters involved in the 2nd half of the tale....and Misa was supposed to be annoying ).
 
I haven't read a ton of manga (yet), but I will mention a few that deserve serious consideration:

Ranma 1/2: It has everything; laughs, drama, interesting characters, etc...

Initial D: How many mangas that have such a focus on cars could appeal to so many on-car fans? Because of the character development, drama and laughs. Heh.

Cromartie High School: THE funniest comic series I have EVER read! Nothing else has even come close for me. I don't often laugh out loud while reading, but this series has me doing just that on a regular basis, even in the presence of other people.
 
What, you mean Monday as in today, or as in one week from today? 'Cause the former seems ridiculously short and the latter seems ridiculously long. In any case....


1.) Berserk
2.) Genshiken
3.) Dragon Ball
4.) Gantz
5.) One Piece
6.) Hellsing
7.) Akira
8.) Death Note
9.) Naruto
10.) Kenshin
 
Yes, Bakuman is my favorite currently running Jump manga. Honestly, very little about it has annoyed me at all, unlike Death Note which did rub me the wrong way a few times. I like that the main characters are more down to earth and the story moves at a brisk pace. Don't get me wrong, they might make a wrong move and blow it down the road, but as it is it's simply great.

And there is no excuse for Misa. NONE!
 
My list:
1. Monster
2. Bersek
3. Dragonball
4. One Piece
5. Ruruoni Kenshin
6. Fullmetal Alchemist
7. Death Note
8. Naruto
9. Fruits Basket
10. Akira
 
I'm fine with my lack of CLAMP, and I'm sure they wouldn't make my list anyway. I do need to read some seinen, though, since I tend to like seinen anime more than shonen anime or manga.
 
This is really difficult... I'll give it a shot nonetheless...

1- Hunter X Hunter: Hunter X Hunter is filled to the brim with creative ideas, surprising twists and good old fashion shonen goodness. Its one of the few stories I know where the training is not only emphasized on but is made just as entertaining as the fights themselves. In fact the fights are actually far and few most of the time but when they happen they always blow my mind with the level of strategy involved. Togashi made away with the usual comentator you see in Shonen stories by giving us a glimpse of the thought process of the parties involved. The story never progresses exactly like you expect it and no matter how talented they are Gon and Killua are never shown as the best of the best. Hunter X Hunter also has Nen with its nearly academic level of complexity.

2- Black Jack: I HAD to have a Tezuka manga in my list and Black Jack is my favorite out of the few I've read. Its main character is complex and you only discover his backstory bits by bits. One who first seemed amoral enRAB up being mostly a dark vigilente of the medical world. Tezuka's own medical training allows him to know exactly where to be faithful to reality and where to invent facts. Black Jack is a classic exemple of Tezuka's style and treat to anyone who read it.

3- Genshiken: Who here wouldn't like to be part of that group? To get in on the mundane but so delightful shenaningans going on? Genshiken is a psychological essay on what it means to be a fan, an adult and both at the same time. Its criminally short yet at the same time it doesn't outstay its welcome and become repetitive. It goes out in top form.

4- Hoshin Engi: Give a Sci-fi mangaka the task of remaking a classic Chinese novel and what do you get? An AMAZING shonen. Filled with epic battles, an incredibly large cast of diverse character that may all suddenly die on you without warning, and a lazy protagonist who succeed through a corabination of cleverness, with, and the charisma to motivate his more powerful allies. Hoshin Engi also has an amazing design where things look futuristic yet fit in with ancient China. It was a crazy ride.

5- Et Cetera: I had to give a shoutout to this obscure little gem by Tow Nakazaki. Its a nine volume story set in the Old West and centering on Mingchao, a young orphan Chinese girl who must protect a magical gun powered by the magic of the Chinese Zodiac from the forces of an evil drug ring. The cast of character is likeable, the story is short without being rushed, and Nakazaki's style is just so much likeable. Just looking at the characters you can't help but like them! It has no shortage of action and humor and is a thrill ride from start to finish!

6- Samurai Deeper Kyo : This is one of those rare cases where it turns out the main character is actually the strongest character in the serie right from the start, but that we the reader just don't know the extent of his power. From mundane swordfight to epic lightspeed attack the progression of Samurai Deeper Kyo into epic-dom was amazing. The anime really cut too short, leaving out amazing characters. The art of this serie is one of the best I've seen in the genre, with beautiful costumes, expressive face and impressive attacks.

7- Saint Seiya - The Lost Canvas: Lots of shonen on this list huh? As much as I LOVE the original Saint Seiya for its hot blooded action and archetypical characters it was a mess of rushed and improvised story with simplistic art and in retrospect is memorable for its mythology but not a great manga. The Lost Canvas (and Episode G as well but I had to pick only one) fixes a lot of issues, giving us more development of the characters than the original did with a great story of frienRABhip, betrayal and the destruction of the world all wrapped in beautiful art that remind one of Kurumada's style but transcend it at the same time. It also gives us more focus on the female characters, something Kurumada's story was somewhat lacking.

8- Eyeshield 21 : I never cared much for Football until I started Eyeshield 21 on a whim. The story of Sena and the Deimon Devil Bat is filled with the hot-blooded action I love, wrapped in tensed matches where every little second counts. The finale to the incredibly tense match between the Devil Bats and the White Knights had me turning the pages just so fast... Volumes are read at the speed of light and leave me wanting more. Its expensive cast of fascinating character is all well designed and you can't help but root for the likeable rivals like the Wild Gunman or White Knights. This manga also had me nearly in tears on more than one occasion.

9- Monster: I put it this low mostly because A) everybody is going to vote for it and B) because I haven't actually read it all. I put it here because I know its a great manga, even if its not something that tickled me that much.

10- FLCL : I know a lot of folks who don't like the manga, but its such a different experience from the anime and it gives us a different perspective on the story that I can't help enjoy both for different reason. I love the crazy artstyle of this short story. Its lacking in a few characters that were in the anime though. I wanted something different and crazy in my last spot and I know no crazier manga.

Well there's my list. I could have find a space for Leiji Matsumoto in there somewhere... I still haven't finished Galaxy Express 999 but I did finish Harlock (doesn't really 'end' though). There's bunch of stuff I'd like to add in there but I just don't have the space.

I'm sure I won't even see half of my picks in the final list.
 
1. One Piece
2. History Strongest Dispcle Kenchi
3. Fruits Basket
4. Rurouni Kenshin
5. Bobobobobobobo
6. Detective Conan
7. Bleach
8. GetBackers
9. Fushigi Yugi
10. Inuyasha
 
I'm not much of a manga reader, I could barely complete this list, Other than the top two here every manga I've read I've read exclusively because the anime doesn't provide closure. But hey, that's a different perspective than some, so might as well rate what I could

1. Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind
2. Ranma 1/2
3. Kare Kano/ His and Her Circumstances
4. Love Hina
5. Fruits Basket
6. Genshiken
7. Alien Nine
8. School Rurable
9. Hayate No Gotoku/ Hayate the Corabat Butler
10. Ai Yori Aoshi
 
Pshhhh....that "rubbing" you the wrong way thing is just personal bias towarRAB Death Note.

The point of Light is that he's supposed to be an egotistical maniac with an insane god-complex. The characters in DN are meant to be anything but down-to-Earth, whereas the characters in Bakuman are meant to be normal people who lead normal lives.

Also, my excuse for Misa not totally ruining the series is that its interesting to see how Light actually ended up using her to his advantage, and how she can also endanger and/or actually screw up his plans during many parts in the series. She actually adRAB a tad bit more tension to the plot, in that regard. That, and the fact that a certain something happens to her by the end of the series makes-up for her annoyance (even though you don't actaully get to see it happen ).

I do agree that Bakuman is great, though. However, my 1 knock against its characters is that they aren't very consistent throughout the series, and not all of that seems to be due to intended character development, unlike in Death Note.

At any rate, the reason for why I didn't rank Bakuman on my list is because I'm still waiting to see if it maintains its overall quality past the first 100 chapters of it (since you just know that its going to go on for at least 100 chapters, with where the story is at right now, if not much more). If it does stay this good, then it will probably become a top 5 for me, and take GTO's spot on my list.
 
There's no bias towarRAB Death Note here, I like Death Note. I also liked Hikaru No Go slightly more than Death Note, too (If that counts), it's just not one of my favorites. I love noir, I love manga, and I like this team. Death Note just lingered a bit too long for my tastes and didn't quite maintain it's quality. (Although I have absolutely no issue with the manga ending at all like some people, it's pretty well done.)

I know she's supposed to be annoying, and she succeeRAB. Too freaking well.

Also, I've found the character development in Bakuman very organic to the characters, even through the events that occur the characters still manage to subtly change and add nuances to themselves. It's quite interesting to see. My only complaint is that I don't like the manga Ashirogi Muto is currently doing, but that might just be a personal preference thing. I wouldn't have voted for it in the questionnaires.
 
I was actually hoping that Ashirogi's new manga would be something more along the lines of Death Note, actually.

But, anyways, I'm getting off-topic here, so we can talk more about this on the actual thread that exists for Bakuman.
 
Back
Top