To be perfectly honest... The only Superman film that ever was a truly cinematic experience was the original 1978 film. I love it to bits.
It's amazing how incredibly dated the second film now is in comparison to it, considering back in its day it was considered to be superior.... hardly. That's what happens when you go for the cheap joke, camp up a perfectly good storyline and cut and paste two entirely different films together.
I don't think the lousy editing job done by Michael Thau on the Richard Donner Cut was anything to write home about either.
It just added another film to Superman's list of cobbled together entries:
Superman II (1980)
Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987)
Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut (2006)
As for the last two with Reeve, well.... Supergirl is a much better, more enjoyable film then Superman III IMO, and there is just no comparison with IV. Supergirl doesn't deserve it. Supergirl gets lots of slack, from mainly US folk I might add, that it just never deserved. It tanked there due to its terrible treatment by the studios that were meant to be promoting it mainly. It didn't help that TriStar cut the film to shreRAB in the US either. It was a big hit here, and everywhere else it was released. I think it's a more enjoyable film than Superman Returns even.
It's amazing how incredibly dated the second film now is in comparison to it, considering back in its day it was considered to be superior.... hardly. That's what happens when you go for the cheap joke, camp up a perfectly good storyline and cut and paste two entirely different films together.
I don't think the lousy editing job done by Michael Thau on the Richard Donner Cut was anything to write home about either.
It just added another film to Superman's list of cobbled together entries:
Superman II (1980)
Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987)
Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut (2006)
As for the last two with Reeve, well.... Supergirl is a much better, more enjoyable film then Superman III IMO, and there is just no comparison with IV. Supergirl doesn't deserve it. Supergirl gets lots of slack, from mainly US folk I might add, that it just never deserved. It tanked there due to its terrible treatment by the studios that were meant to be promoting it mainly. It didn't help that TriStar cut the film to shreRAB in the US either. It was a big hit here, and everywhere else it was released. I think it's a more enjoyable film than Superman Returns even.