I agree I kind of lean toward the more polished Metallica version, and I like varioius mooRAB/segments it goes through, while Mechanics is more straight-forward.
I like their last album a lot too, I still think Souvlaki is the best album though. If you compiled their first 3/4 EPs and made it an album it would be the best. Blue Day is awesome too. What a fantastic mindblowing band. I think they're top 10 for me.
I saw them on the California tour in a small club, amazing show but that particular song/performance doesn't really do much for me. I prefer the studio version (with all the samples included).
aww dude you're really hurting me with this one hahaha but i gotta side with Jane's. though Underwater Love is definitely one of my favourite tracks from The Real Thing.