Imam XIII The Fallible
New member
**STRICTLY FOR SHIITES, Sunnis pls restrain, but you may leave ur view there, but please no dialogues**
---------
1. Did Muhammad (s) ever say 'ya ali madad'?
2. Did Ali (AS) ever ask his sheeas to say 'ya ali'?
3. How did this practise begin?
I want references from your own set of Al-kafi, balagah, Bihaar al-Anwar etc or from authentic sunni sources.
====thnx=====
The Shee'aa : you naseybi Koranist don't deserve an answer!
Sonja : sure, sure, nice dodge
*giggles*
Nova..........LOOOOOOOOOOOOOL
99..sarcasm speaks a lot, dont try to hide ur ignorance by the show of arrogance.
Thats why Sonja never liked blind faith.
'A CHILD SAYS, �O Mother Help!� then it is all right for you people, but when he says, �O Ali Help!!!� then it is shirk for you???''
The reasoning is flawed, a child is not accountable for his/her actions, but a grown person is.
Irani: Sonja have always discussed her faith with her father alone. Mother is mother irrelevent that she muslim or non-muslim.
elda state ur source, Sonja needs a read the article herself.
[5:35] O you who believe, you shall reverence GOD and seek the ways and means to Him, and strive in His cause, that you may succeed.
elda state ur source, Sonja needs *to read the article herself.
---------
1. Did Muhammad (s) ever say 'ya ali madad'?
2. Did Ali (AS) ever ask his sheeas to say 'ya ali'?
3. How did this practise begin?
I want references from your own set of Al-kafi, balagah, Bihaar al-Anwar etc or from authentic sunni sources.
====thnx=====
The Shee'aa : you naseybi Koranist don't deserve an answer!
Sonja : sure, sure, nice dodge
*giggles*
Nova..........LOOOOOOOOOOOOOL
99..sarcasm speaks a lot, dont try to hide ur ignorance by the show of arrogance.
Thats why Sonja never liked blind faith.
'A CHILD SAYS, �O Mother Help!� then it is all right for you people, but when he says, �O Ali Help!!!� then it is shirk for you???''
The reasoning is flawed, a child is not accountable for his/her actions, but a grown person is.
Irani: Sonja have always discussed her faith with her father alone. Mother is mother irrelevent that she muslim or non-muslim.
elda state ur source, Sonja needs a read the article herself.
[5:35] O you who believe, you shall reverence GOD and seek the ways and means to Him, and strive in His cause, that you may succeed.
elda state ur source, Sonja needs *to read the article herself.