I read the bad reviews and was gutted, I so love this movie. I might be going to see it for the third time on wednesday. Its so amazing.
I do understand what you're saying (I also agree I felt I should applaud)
However, when he takes her down is my favourite bit, probably because of the music, hehhe. However I think there is a sag between this and the masquerade section... the whole Carlotta thing I'm not keen on, and when they sing about letter.
Though I agree that after maquerade is get really good. I love the way they did the point of no return. The whole ending rocked, I just annoyed when people say its overlong. I just wish things go and on and on so I loved the fact the ending took a while to come!