Every single teenybopper actor and actress out there is overrated. Hillary Duff, Chad Michael Murray, Lindsay Lohan, Ashton Kutcher, the Olsen twins, Frankie Muniz, Jessica Alba, Nick Cannon, and so on.
With the possible exception of Amanda Bynes (I said "possible").
They're overrated because it's not even about their talent (or lack thereof), it's about the new "insert actor's name" movie. And not in the Clive Owen, Don Cheadle, Emma Thompson, Bruce Willis kinds way where these actors actually go out of their way to... wait for it... actually act.
The teenybopper movies are all about "watch Hillary be cute and innocent" and "watch Jessica be hot" or "see Nick Cannon be cool" and "see Chad Michael Murray be a pseudo-thinking version of a shallow hot guy"...
That's not acting. That's product placement. So, for all I know they actually have talent, but it doesn't matter. Enough of those.
And it translates into adult actors, too, but to a lesser extent. Movies about "Tom Cruise - Action Hero" or, egads, even "Robert DeNiro - Former BadAss Turned Into Spoof of Himself" do not interest me.
Now, as far as I'm concerned, Tom Cruise was never a good actor. Now he's a whack job to boot, but he always pretty much sucked. He's the quintessential teenybopper ("watch Tom Cruise be good-looking in a car, in a plane, in a bar..." turned adult.
Robert DeNiro is obviously one of the most brilliant actors we have. But what the hell's happened to him? I'm sick of seeing parodying himself. He did the freaking Rocky and Bullwinkle movie, for pete's sakes!!! Enough!