To get the '09 fender to fit you will need alot of work. To increase the tire size and stuff, you will need a new swingarm and such also. Any touring rear fender from '99 to '08 will fit your bike. The only thing you need to watch out for is that some fenders (Road King Custom, for example) don't have the hole for the bumper light on the bottom. However, the fenders without the whole are not very common at all, I tried to find one after getting hit in the rear and most of the fenders I could find had the hole. I ended up contacting a local custom painter and he took a take off Road King Classic fedner, welded the hole, and painted it for much less than a brand new one!