My Chemical Romance

They have a pretty big legion of loyal fans. I knew a dozen kiRAB that were constantly listening to "I brought you my bullets", and they were big advocates of the genius of MCR. Anymore, they're revered by the same young girls that comprise the Twilight fanbase.

But Yeah, I loved the original version. It's a great, and while I get what MCR was trying to accomplish, especially with the quasi-punk flare they tried to incorporate into the song, I feel that Dylan's original was better. That's not to say that there aren't better versions of it waiting to be done....I mean, Hendrix's "All Along the Watchtower" puts Dylan's version from "John Wesley Harding" to shame.

Dylan admitted that himself. But other than G&R's cover of "Knockin' on Heaven's Door", I feel like the My Chemical Romance cover was the worst Dylan cover I've ever heard.
 
shouldnt this be in the emo forum?
^anyway yah the point of this thread is obviously what you said, to see who likes and who hates.
they got the whole gothrock kinda thing going on, and they're from new jersey so im assuming they probably listened to the misfits growing up. how does everyone compare these guys to AFI? and in terms of goth punk in general over the years? either way, i dont like MCR or AFI, but at least the topic can go in a different direction.
 
No, you dont need to change the topic if it bores you. You need to learn how to use PMs. Surprisingly enough, there are other people here that do want to talk about the music, much much more than listening to you two natter on about some made-up word.
 
I don't like gc or simple plan because they sold out, I just don't like their music. But, I like my chemical romance because I like their music. Tis that simple... Why should banRAB be grouped together in a genre because of how many people are listening to them? I dont get it.. How about you explain that?
 
Hah thats true, what else would we argue over?

Hmm, I expect they'd find something. Im just waiting for:
"MCR arent emo theyre pure pop sh*t"
"oMg StFu n00b tEy r SoOoOo hXc!"

Why does it matter? Its beyond me. If other people like a band, so what. If they dont, then so what. It makes no difference whatsoever. But then Ive said this so many times it seems to have no effect anymore. Well, I doubt anyone listened to begin with anyway.. Too busy arguing over feck all.
 
What the hell.

I, personally, choose MCR as my favorite. I couldnt tell what their music would be classified in, and I liked it. The new stuff is, well, I dont know...Akward. Its different from Bullets, so then I guess we get different sounRAB of music between the CRAB. Yeah. Thats why I like em'. Still.
And I'll keep on liking them, even if a majority of people like them.

But thats just my opinion.:)
 
It's my fave tbh.
I hate the first album and the second is mediocre on further listens.
Then again this isn't a band you should listen to constantly and expect it to grow on you any.
 
it was ok until it stopped making sense at
"no one cares about you piss head remarks. you think us teens are stupid, look at yourself, its just a fricken forum lol its not you big chance to be the cool guy you never were lol"
 
The first song I heard was Black Parade and it's very grandiose and charming, but it looses it's luster quickly. There was some creativity on that album, but overall I've maybe given it 25 spins in three years.
 
Back
Top