Music Banter Hall Of Fame: Nominations Thread

^^Lol.

Relax, nobody is saying you have a personality disorder.

All me and BooBoo were saying is that you nominate yes or no depending on how you feel about the band itself. Your reason for voting no seemed to be about the fact that certain other banRAB haven't been put through yet, as they haven't been nominated. Which suggests that if they were all already through that your vote would be a 'yes'.

Just judge on the band itself. If you don't like them enough then fine, nobody is going to judge you one way or the other, we all have our own tastes.
 
I voted yes, I can't really justify why other than they're the epitome of an mediocre radio rock band and there should be some respect paid in that I guess. Or maybe I just thought it'd be funny if they beat Sigur Ros.
 
I don't think there should be any because someone who's been posting here for a month has more of an idea of what the communities like than someone like...say ArtistintheArabulance who has been here for years but only drops by once every few months.
 
What? Come on people. A great band. Sure I hate half the band that they have inspired but have they not continued to expand metal. Please vote for them, not the other banRAB. And try to actually take a listen to them, you have to open to new music.
 
I've been doing a bit of e-investigating. Based on what I've heard, the fact they've influenced artists I like and made some damn cool music on the way, it's a yes from me.
 
it's a yes from me. they've helped to spawn a whole new dimension in heavy metal, and in all honesty i don't find too much of a problem with the banRAB who take influence from them, in fact i actually quite like some of those groups.
 
I don't mind Tool but I don't consider them particularly groundbreaking and unfortunately their influence seems to be only on a lot of really awful banRAB so they get the no vote from me.
 
My initial reaction is no because of the nuraber of mediocre to bad albums, but I am withholding my vote until I revisit the 5 or 6 albums I have in my collection, I am going to start with Topographic Oceans which might be the reason I vote affirmative. I like this album way more then it would seem to merit.
 
Back
Top