Mines is by far the original, however I loved the 2nd one as well. Devon Sawa and Ali Larter were both fantastic in the first movie. The deaths weren't gruesome enough to make you nearly sick, however they were definately a bit hard to watch and Terry's death was SO sudden!
It definately made me jump when it happened. What I didn't understand was how death supposedly "skipped" Alex (after he sacrificed himself for Clear), but then returned to try and kill him in Paris? If Death skipped Alex, why did he wait three months then go to Paris and attempt to kill him again? It was a bit confusing. That aside - I loved the characters and I thought the premonition was very realistic.
I enjoyed the 2nd one as well. I thought the characters of Kat and Rory were hilarious. The deaths in this film were alot more gruesome (the premonition, Evan being impaled, Nora's head stuck in the lift, Kat getting impaled through the head) but it actually felt like a horror film and we got to know all the characters before their inevitable death.
The 3rd one was awful. I think the main problem was the focus on the two main characters and not enough screen time for the others. The first two films let us get to know the other characters, but in this film the only time we saw the others was at the premonition and then at their death scenes, so I didn't really care much.
I hope the 4th one is better than the 3rd at least!

I enjoyed the 2nd one as well. I thought the characters of Kat and Rory were hilarious. The deaths in this film were alot more gruesome (the premonition, Evan being impaled, Nora's head stuck in the lift, Kat getting impaled through the head) but it actually felt like a horror film and we got to know all the characters before their inevitable death.
The 3rd one was awful. I think the main problem was the focus on the two main characters and not enough screen time for the others. The first two films let us get to know the other characters, but in this film the only time we saw the others was at the premonition and then at their death scenes, so I didn't really care much.
I hope the 4th one is better than the 3rd at least!