Does anyone agree Adam Vinatieri is the best NFL kicker of all time?

A

Aron N

New member
He has won 4 super bowls, he is the only kicker to play in 5 super bowls, and he has won 2 super bowls with the patriots by kicking a game winning field goal as time expired in both those 2 super bowls to win the super bowl. Agree he's the best?
 
Super Bowl rings does not indicate greatness at any position..... not QB, not RB & most definitely not KICKER. Super Bowl rings are a team achievement no matter what ESPN tells ya.

As far as him being great..... he was great w/ NE, i think he's still a closet fan & I wouldn't care if he ever wore a Colts jersey again
 
I don't think he is the GOAT kicker, but he is one of the most clutch and will probably be in the HOF.
I still think Blanda will go down as the best kicker, because he could do so much more, as well. Of course it was also a different era.

Being the only kicker to be in 5 Super Bowls is a great accomplishment, but it doesn't automatically make you the GOAT. He wasn't the sole reason those 5 teams made it to the Super Bowl.
 
Back
Top