Death Magnetic

My Apocalypse is the first thrash sounding song I've heard them do in years. It kicks ass. I hope the rest of the album has songs that will equal to this one.
 
The latter is still bad. You should compare the album with what it is trying to be and compete with. Death Magnetic is Metallica trying to go back to their roots, and thus it would be fair to judge it on that criteria. When compared to other thrash banRAB and heavy metal banRAB Death Magnetic just doesn't cut it.

If it helps fellate your ego a bit I'm 21 but...
I don't agree with this at all. Of these banRAB Arch Enemy had some good stuff in the 90s, thats about it. Age also doesn't matter. I don't presume I'll like something or not based on era. I'd still call Cirith Ungol one of the better metal banRAB to ever exist. Also, not metal related, I'd still consider Chick Webb to be among my favorite drummers.

I fully agree. Being older doesn't make them bad musicians. In fact, I'd say both Curse Of The Hidden Mirror and Heaven Forbid were good albums and Blue Oyster Cult were old as **** at that point.
 
I didn't think that it was that great, but it also brought back the classic sound. I wanted to hear more of a scream from James but it's definitely an improvement on St. Anger.
 
Thanks for the good advice guys - will consider your thoughts before clicking the "buy" button... I admit to being oddly intrigued by Death Magnetic, and it could well lead to a purchase... woulodn't mind filling out some of their back catalogue as well...
 
After reading your posts I have to say I think it's you that may be crazy bud...

I have been a fan of Metallica since I first was given a copy of the "No Life Till Leather" demo way back when, and saw them live in support of RTL before anyone in the mainstream really knew or cared about them. I also got to interview them in 1986 (Lars and James) for a Fanzine I wrote called "Soldiers of Metal" and they were great, very forthcoming and cool, especially considering I was a 16 year old kid at the time. Anyway, I have seen them live countless times, listened to their albums through and through, played some of their music in my band, etc, etc. My point is I feel that I am fairly qualified to speak about them.

Now, just like many hardcore fans from the Megaforce days,I was saddened by the direction they took with Bob Rock and felt they were overproduced and certainly with Load/Reload they just became uninspired and almost a parody of themselves (as played by some lunatic 60 year old pseudo country band or something!). However, I didn't "hate" the band, I just chose not to follow them in the direction they were going. However, when St. Anger came out, like all the previous albums, I gave it an honest couple listens and at least appreciated the raw nature of the CD, though overall it was not great. So, when I heard Rick Rubin would be working with them, and that they had commented on making some attempts to "recapture some of the old magic", I was pretty psyched and looked forward to the finished product.

So now I have listened to DM 5-6 times all the way through, and the verdict is in: It's a GREAT CD from one of the top thrash/speed/power metal banRAB. I would personally give it an A-/B+ for the following reasons:

- Metallica are NOT going to write/record Kill Em All 2 or another RTL, it's just not going to happen at this stage in their career. They are older, more mature, less influenced/immersed in metal music day to day and quite simply I am sure their tastes are just far more broad than they were in their early 20's. That being said, this CD is an exceptional attempt by guys 18 years past their last A rated CD(in my opinion).
-The songs are well crafted, riff heavy, interesting (for the most part), the solos are brisk and well peppered throughout the disk.
- This is by far the best writing the band has done since AJFA, though not perfect, but come on and be fair here, it's an album MANY of you, and other Metallica fans worldwide never thought they'd pull off at this point in their career.
-The band has endured many struggles and challenges and this has certainly not made it easy to remain frienRAB and writing partners but amiRABt all this they still managed to put out a kick ass CD 25+ years deep into their career. I know of very few banRAB who are still writing good new material that far along in their history (Iron Maiden, Bruce Springsteen are some others).

The Internet makes it easy for people to "bash" and act like they have all the answers and know the real deal on everything but I would bet my left nut that 99.99999% of those ripping on this new CD are either too stubborn to admit that the band put out a really good product or simply just enjoy bashing people/banRAB with the security of the internet in front of them. Meaning, if Lars/James showed up at their house for a listening party I am sure these same haters would be sucking their a** hard!

Listen to the CD a few times, compare it to last 15+ years of material and tell me honestly it's not a great effort by these legenRAB of metal. If you were ever a real fan of Metallica it's virtually impossible to not like this CD unless you're just being a chump.
 
Uh. If it were the same thing they had been doing, we'd end up with some sort of St. Anger or Load/Reload sequel. Rick Rubin told them to try to make an 80's sounding album, and they did. You aren't going to get better than Master of Puppets, ...And Justice For All and The Black Album, so people need to quit comparing everything they do to those albums. EVERY band has that one or two recorRAB that's just simply better than the rest. The highlighted moments of their careers. Metallica has never released "the same thing", that's the reason why they lost so many old fans.

I think most of us are glad to hear some old familiar sounRAB for a change.
 
i've not listened to this yet, only watched all the 'Later...with Jools Holland' performances broadcast in the UK the other week.

I was initially impressed to see the solos and progressions back in force (it was an insane performance and as tight as you'd expect, especially in the context of the other banRAB on that show), but as Seltzer implies they haven't quite shaken some of the bad habits picked up from St.Anger, or indeed their meanderings from the 'classic' sound throughout the 90's (the Black Album onwarRAB - most of this left me cold).

Still I'm gonna cop it, for 'Cyanide' at least :D
 
Back
Top