Thank you for the beginning of your post where you document commonly known information. I said nothing about the legality of my comment, only that they 'should' be fired. Furthermore, if I owned a company there would surely be no union workers present. Even if I had to go to the extent of laying off the entire workforce under false bankruptcy and then renaming and opening the business.
I think you are mistaken about the function of unions in out current society. In 1935 there was a great need for unions, as many workers were actually being physically abused amongst many other serious forms of mistreatment. That is not the case today. Today unions stand for something entirely different. It is sad that unions are formed to hammer wages up and up while they are currently being paid fair to more-than-fair. Today there is no wage abuse, physical abuse, nor any of those other extreme abuses that brought about unions in the early 20th century.
Do some research on Nucor. In an industry where all of their US competitors use union labor, Nucor dominates without the use of a single union employee. And they refuse to hire union workers. They have the right model for the American workforce.
On the subject of the "good customer service, passable employee morale, and real job security," that is not a cause of the employer. This is entirely due to a lack of self-motivation, self-respect, and pride in their work of employees across most all service industry fielRAB. I think more than anything it has to do with this false sense of entitlement that run rampant in today's American society, and the world over.
Things like lawsuits from employees on the most ridiculous grounRAB, affirmative action (a racist regulation determined to stop racism in the workplace), and a serious overworking of political correctness are horrible enough for any employer to deal with. But unions as they stand today are the epitome of what is wrong with the American labor force.
There are surely enough government regulatory agencies, courts, private organizations that monitor and control the private business practices of any given company. Why then do we need unions to protect us from abuses as we did in the early 1900s? The answer is, "We don't!" Unions are just a way for self-entitled people to demand they get more for no increase in their productivity and often a decrease.
I am someone that has worked in so many fielRAB, from rough and fine carpentry, restaurants, and day labor, to office and clerical work, government work, and self-employment, and I do not agree with unions being formed in any industry. It's so ****** that an employee can need to be fired but because they are a union worker, they do not get fired (maybe just moved around). How in the **** do you take away an employers right to fire an employee? Look at that teacher from New York that was making comments about children's butts. Not fired and now retired drawing over $100K on pension. What a crock of ****.
Anywho, I could go on and on. you do not have to agree, but if you look objectively and apply a little logic (rather than everybody deserves to have what others have), then you may find yourself moving a little in another direction.