Dog Man Star is fantastic. Since you like it, I'd suggest Head Music. In my opinion, it is Suede's best album. I think "Everything Flows" and "Down" are two of their best songs ever, and every track is a winner.
I'm currently obsessed by Vampire Weekend's debut. A friend sent it to me many months ago, but I only just now got to it, so I realize I'm rather late to the party. But it's spectacular.
I'm sure this comparison has been made ad nauseam, but it's a masterpiece like Paul Simon's Graceland. Finally, some New York hipster kiRAB who don't sound like New York hipster kiRAB.