Erm, I didn't explain clearly.
I have a "5 Star Playlist" on my iTunes. It's comprised of anything that I enjoy enough to hear on a regular basis. Lots of albums have come very close to earning 5 stars on every song, but until The Betrayed, they've all had at least 1 song preventing that.
So it's not that I think The Betrayed is the best album ever, I just enjoy every single song on the album.