This really is a no-brainer. Daydream Nation wins this easily. Come to think of it, Doolittle would lose against the majority of Sonic Youth albums if I have to choose. And yes, Surfer Rosa is better, at least I like it much, much, much more. (I'm not sure how this makes me pretentious, but whatever, boo boo, whatever)
And since trace posted videos pushing for Doolittle, let us now remind ourselves why Daydream Nation is so powerful