Tyler8Durden, thanks for giving me a good laugh. But before I begin speaking, I suggest you learn how to spell. It'll save your life someday.
Now, let's start with "This is not becasue I'm homophobic or i don't like ignorant, repulsive people!" You do realize that you're placing yourself in our direct line of fire, don't you? It's sort of radiating with irony; so much for music creating a more accepting environment. And while we're on the topic, the word "homophobe" is intended to be insulting, and I hardly doubt someone like you would have half the wit to give reverse psychology a thought.
Also, you don't seem to have any more reason than muzyc does. If you're going to say Elton John sucks, at least say Elton John sucks with a little intelligence. I know the audience would appreciate it, at the least.
As for your well-thought and well-planned arguments, yes, he is a songwriter, and yes, he is a brilliant pianist as well. Your sarcasm does wonders. In case you didn't know, he can also do both at the same time, like a ****ing puppet. It's not safe in the real world to try and insult those that pay for your burial.
Oh, and check your math. "You list 9 songwriters (7 of which i agree with) 2 are Ok, and then you put 'Elton John' at the bottom."
Better luck next time, eh?