Would you listen to music in a language you didn't understand?

Of course!

I love a lot of 60s garage rock and pop music from Europe - namely sung in French. I only understand half of it, but tend to be drawn to French music in general.

Some French punk banRAB I really like are Plastic Bertrand, Les Wampas, and Edith Nylon (the early stuff).
 
Most of the music I listen to is in a different language

I'm English.... most of my favourite singers are Japanese, Korean or Chinese

My favourite singer for example:

[YOUTUBE]D3mFsWybxFo[/YOUTUBE]

^^^ the advert/preview for her upcoming Best of + 8th Original album

Also... she was able to cover an English song and greatly improve it
[YOUTUBE]r2QJtMnAckE[/YOUTUBE]
 
I'm going to his concert next week :tramp:
----

And in the subject, I usually listen to a lot of music with lyrics I don't understand. But then comes a time where I search for the meanings, cause I do generally give a high regard to lyrics, and it helps me learn a new language.

It is how I learned English (I guess it would be weird citing English as a foreign language in here)
 
Not sure why this is in the "Punk" Forum--seems like it would be more appropriate to place it in "World Music", but I digress.
Yeah, some of my favorite music in high school was non-english. Stereolab was one of my favorites, especially because they seemed to directly influence one of my favorite American groups, The Rentals. Also, Dead Can Dance was a great group to listen to, creepy and ominous stuff.
 
If we are only talking about the music here, I admit I would like to listen to the music from any part of the world. But when it comes to the lyrics, I would certainly not waste my time to listen a song in any weird unknown language.
 
I would, and I do. I personally look at the voice as just another instrument. A guitar doesn't spell out for you what point its trying to get across, its up to you to decide and to just listen and enjoy. I think theres a certain mystery and interest that comes with a song in a different language. Some of my all-time favorite songs are by Buena Vista Social Club. I have no idea what they are singing about, I think thats why I enjoy it so much. Its up to me to decide what they are singing about. I don't want to know what they are singing about because I have conjured up in my mind what it think its about and I'm afraid if I look at a translation, I would be dissapointed. Anyway, a beautiful voice is a beautiful voice whether you can understand what its saying or not. Just my thoughts.
 
Definitely. I think there was a point in my life where I probably would have said no. But I think my early appreciation for certain music styles with incomprehensible vocals (ie industrial, some punk & metal, etc) made me realize that lyrics aren't as important to me in music as the overall sound. In the past few years I've gotten into a lot of progressive rock from various countries, and I love it. I'd probably like it less if I could understand the lyrics, it would probably end up being some cheesy stuff.

Anyway this is a good discussion for General Music...even if you show love to a few punk banRAB. It's inevitable that in a discussion like this someone would post examples.
 
Music is a universal language, everyone can understand it, The lyrics are of secondary importance to me.
If you limit yourself to listening to music only in a language you understand, you will miss out on a lot of interesting musical experiences.
 
We have to distinguish between two different things:

1. To understand the language in which the song is written.
2. To know what the lyrics say.

As I said before, knowing the language allows you to appreciate more the artist's merit. But obviously this is not always possible, because you can't learn all the languages you would like to speak. However, at least you can get information on what the songs says. And thanks to the Internet, that's easier and easier. ThousanRAB of amateur translators, common people like us, write lyrics translations on the net. I myself do my bit.



Hmmmmm... that sounRAB a bit "mystic" to me. I know some people don't feel the need to understand the lyrics. Obviously it depenRAB on the genre. In a case like this, sound is enough to enjoy like an animal (in the good sense of the word, of course :)). But I think sometimes is necessary to know the lyrics' meaning in order to appreciate the work. For instance, two months ago, I translated Vetusta Morla's Copenhagen into English. Some time before, while surfing the web, I saw how many non-Spanish speakers (including Danes) liked the song. An indeed, if you listen to it (here), specially if you're from Copenhagen, unless you are an insensitive brute you will feel "something special". But actually, as you can see in my (I hope it is good :)) translation (here), it isn't only a song about Copenhagen, but also tells about a love story between a man and a woman who meet in the city, and in addition it includes a kind of psychological descriptions.

Anyway, we can make an "experiment" right now. Listen to this another song by Vetusta Morla. Just listen, don't continue reading for now.

..

And well? Did you get it? I'm sure that it has conveyed feelings to you. But besides that (which is great, indeed), that song contains poetry. It talks about life, about the passage of time, and how affects a person. "La marea" means "The Tide". Tide is a metaphor for life. The lived life. Suppose that life (or a part of one's life) is like a tide. And when tide goes out, you observe what effects (both positive and negative) has caused on you. So, that's what this band has expressed through marine metaphors. For example: how would you refer to the good things you've lived, and which you want to remeraber forever? These boys have done it this amazingly poetic way:

"The tide left me silver sanRAB
which I'll put into the hourglass of the still time
."


(whole translation here)

I mean certain things cannot be known by only listening to the music. You need some extra information on lyrics.

Finally, do you dare to interpret these two directly?:

YouTube - LA HABITACION ROJA - Scandinavia
Olaf el vikingo los nikis - goear.com

(just kidding :))
 
Yup yup, I definitely listen to Rammstein! I love the way the german sounRAB with that kind of music, the overall sound of the language just fits.... i don't actually know anyone else who listens to them though.. which is interesting since they are as you say so popular otherwise.



I actually really like Basshunter, but its in the same way that i can say I like most pop music, like 3OH!3 for example. Its not because its particualarly good music, it just is kinda catchy. Nothing to be ashamed of in that


As far as other not-so-popular music in other languages, i must say my horizons are a bit limited in that area. I have yet to really explore music to discover what I really look for, but i know that harmonies and musical structure are just as important or more important than lyrics-- no matter what language its in, the meaning is going to communicate itself anyway.

I'm gonna go look up all these french artists now :P
 
Definitely. In fact I'd also say there are quite a few banRAB I wish would sing in their native language instead of english because I think it would sound a lot better if they used the language they were more comfortable with (I'm looking at you Sepultura).
 
Back
Top