It's definitely in my top 5 of favorite movies. I love it because of how Realistic it was. And you could feel the chemistry between Andrew and Sam. They had only known each other for such a little amount of time, but they were truly in love and I could feel what they felt while watching the movie. Also, I love the random knight that his friend's mother was sleeping with.
Side note: There are tons of people in love with Bella and Edward in the Twilight movies...but I could barely see any chemistry between them in the movies. It all was way too forced. I mean, I loved the books, but the movie was pretty horrible. My point here is that people should go out and rent Garden State instead to see genuine looking true love.