Was Steve McNair the greatest player in Titans/Oilers history?

[Rams]

I would say yes, Earl Campbell i feel would be #2

 

[M. Diego]

Bruce Matthews and Earl Campbell my friend.

I don't think McNair will be a Hall of Famer.

 

[....J E R R Y]

There now saying it was a murder /suicide


And he possibly was in their organization...great QB anyways

 

[Tyler L]

No. Bruce Mathews, Earl Campbell, Albert Haynesworth, and Eddie George were.

 

[sonny]

Nah, in the 90s maybe. Not all-time.

 

[Thomas Jefferson Rocks!]

Titans maybe, but no way Oilers! Campbell, Kenny Houston, Curly Culp, Bruce Matthews, etc.

 

[David E]

Earl Campbell
Bruce Matthews
Eddie George
Warren Moon
Haywood Jeffries - Ernest Givens - Drew Hill ( that whole run 'n' shoot receiving core)
Elvin Bethea
Derrick Mason

McNair comes in somewhere around 5th or 6th, I'd say. Gotta take the HOFers (Matthews, Campbell, George, Moon) before Steve enters the discussion.

 

[Sloobap]

I have to say I agree with Thomas Jefferson theres alot of great oilers, he mentioned a few greats and if I sat down and thought about it could remember more how bout Billy White Shoes Johnson

 

[Hammer]

Hell No.

Just because somebody dies, doesn't mean that we have to say they were better than they were. Not even the top quarterback.

 

[The man with no name]

Earl Campbell #1