have to disagree on claymore, I think Haberkorn killed roki, i mean im pretty sure they wanted it to be kind of annoying, but i found it SO annoying that it literally made me not want to watch the show. I mean that sounds harsh but thats how i felt. and i Started watching the show dubbed, so its not like i knew what the subs were like.
I actually have (i think on this forum somewhere) posts were i talk about dropping Claymore because i wasnt into it, but it ended up being the dubs. i switched to subs and ended up loving the show and rocketing right through it .
Ghost hunt, while not bad, i wouldnt put into a "good" category either. Same as claymore, i got bored with the show, switched to the sub and loved it.. go figure that the emotions of the characters can realy make or break a show for me. .. reminds me i actually left ghost hunt in my pending category with only a few eps left.. oops
I think that for a dub to be "awesome" it needs to just be amazing. they have to make the voices really fit like a glove.
To me some shows that have pulled that off to the point where i actually will chose the Dub over the Sub are:
Darker than Black
Black Lagoon
Macross II the movie
Hellsing
Cowboy Bebop
Air Gear
Appleseed
Baccano!
Blood the last vampire
Code Geass
Akira (i enjoy both the orig and the redo honestly)
Street fighter II: the movie
Straight Jacket
Ghost in the Shell (movies and Stand Alone Complex)
FLCL
Kanon
Dubs that are about as good as subs with no clear winner imo:
Blood+
Ergo Proxy
Gun X Sword
Wolf's Rain
Air
Gantz
Shows that i will Not watch the dub because i have too many complaints:
Soul Eater
Clannad
Claymore
Ghost Hunt
Beck (one of my fav animes ever, dont get me started about how they rewrote the songs, changed all the lines that were partially english and partially japanese, which then changed the tension, jokes, reactions to all of those lines.. and rewote a bunch of the script and and ... AHHHHH)
and im sure theres more i could put in each list.. , but without my anime list in front me and scanning through slowly, i cant remember 1/4 of what ive watched lol