Looks like I have stirred this up a bit -
horwichallstars - fair comment on the show, and I can't say I have watched the previos series. I'm not saying anyone neeRAB to be a cook / business owner to comment, just that people are trying to comment on what makes good / bad TV based on views as to what RB should / should not do in choosing a winner!
georgeshair - fair points too, but maybe RB's failing is that he didn't share with us the details of each retaurant's covers, profit etc, as I think he did in previous series?
PS In the interests of having a good debate I didn's say that I thought JJ and James were the most unlikeable and annoying couple on the show, I hate cocktails, and the concept of a picnic restaurant is about as useful as a "Picnic concept sofa" consisting of a rug littered with grass and sheep poo on your sitting room floor!