I don't see a need to scrap this one.
I also placed WR as one of my favorites of 2009 and I seem to remeraber talking about Isis all over the place except for this thread but this is the place for it so I'm a-gonna rant now..
Isis has been one of my favorite banRAB for a long time. They definitely are my favorite 'heavy' band. I like all of their music and I continue to listen to all of their albums at least occasionally. For reference, here's my loose ranking of them:
Oceanic
Panopticon
Celestial
Wavering Radiant
Sgnl>05 ep
Oceanic remixes / reinterpretations (not a real album but whatever)
Mosquito Control / The Red Sea eps (I rate them equally)
In the Absence of Truth
Note: I do not dislike any of them at all. Absence of Truth is a good album but I plain don't like the high concentration of 'clean' singing. However, the production is great and, as every rock journalist mentioned, the drum work improved leaps and bounRAB. But I was seriously worried that this was the beginning of the end for my favorite band. If WR had continued in that direction and Turner dropped the effected growl completely I would have been really disappointed.
The reason I like WR so much is because not only did they not go 'in a more mature direction' or whatever banRAB say when their heavy sound goes light, but they incorporated the lightness with the heavy and also upped the ethereal atmosphere a la Panopticon. The result was even better than I hoped for. I feel that WR was a much bigger step forward than Absence of Truth.
OK, somebody else rant now. I could talk about Isis forever