Oh, I see. I did misunderstand you, then. But what you're mentioning about uTorrent is actually a good thing - torrenting traffic will automatically adjust its speeds depending on what the rest of your programs are doing. Meaning you can max out your upload without making surfing lag, for example, even if you haven't limited your upload speed. And when you aren't doing anything else with your PC, the client will know this and maximize uploading.
To give a rough example, say you're seeding a full speed without uTP and want to check your e-mail or browse this forum. They should load very slowly, because your connection works like a "pipe" - lots of upload going one way prevents your download from coming fast. In this case you'd reduce your upload speed limit as you send your mail or read the new threads, and put it back how it was before when you're done. uTP does exactly the same thing, just transparently.
Maybe so, but the impact shouldn't be noticeable unless you have a very slow upload speed or another application is claiming most of it - and I think you should stop your torrents if you're going to use your upload for something else in the first place.
You have a point there, but looking at the changelog it's mostly bugfixes and performance improvements. Until someone shows actual proof the new uTP favors high-speed peers, I won't believe it.
To give a rough example, say you're seeding a full speed without uTP and want to check your e-mail or browse this forum. They should load very slowly, because your connection works like a "pipe" - lots of upload going one way prevents your download from coming fast. In this case you'd reduce your upload speed limit as you send your mail or read the new threads, and put it back how it was before when you're done. uTP does exactly the same thing, just transparently.
And as a side note, Morris mentions that it's "only the upload" that will be affected. If the upload is throttled, doesn't that ultimately lead to slower download speeds as well?
Maybe so, but the impact shouldn't be noticeable unless you have a very slow upload speed or another application is claiming most of it - and I think you should stop your torrents if you're going to use your upload for something else in the first place.
"uTP has been improved significantly since 1.8.5, with many bugs fixed and performance improvements."
source: http://forum.utorrent.com/viewtopic.php?id=65482
so it may be a much different UTP than what has been there sine UT 1.8.
You have a point there, but looking at the changelog it's mostly bugfixes and performance improvements. Until someone shows actual proof the new uTP favors high-speed peers, I won't believe it.