Subaru Outback (2004) vs Toyota Corolla (2010)?

[PETER GRIFFIN]

Are you kidding?????

Of course a brand new car with a full factory warranty is better!!!!

 

[Melvin C]

Which is the better buy?

Outback ($14000) has 80,000 km mileage and Corolla ($16500) is brand new. Both with warranty.

The condition I am in is 6 months of snow per year. Outback has more space and better vehicle handling in all terrain, but Corolla is new and less lightly to break down.

I am torn between 2 choice. Can I have a an opinion from cyber, and some facts to back the opinion please?