I agree about the visuals and technical aspects!
I like Hayden Christensen, but after a while, I can see how wrong he was for the part. He had no presence. The dialogue wasn't great to begin with, but then you add Christensen moping and slurring his lines... I enjoy some of the scenes, and watching Anakin marching down to kill the Jedis in training will always be chilling and horrible. But the fight with Obi-Wan should have been better, more powerful and hard-hitting!
Hehe. I do like Samuel L. Jackson as Windu mostly because you can tell he's having so much fun.
BTW, Palpatine was so creepy. I always forget how eerie the "transformation" is, and how he takes Anakin down with him makes it even worse.