Why would that be BS? It is no different than what AT$T does with their rebates as well. I can attest to that as I am recently a transfer from AT$T.. somewhat (I still have the account active as there is an issue with the number port, so for now I am keeping AT$T as well for a while so as to not lose my number). But the rebate clauses are standard in my experience with all companies and their dealigs with the smart/business phones (was that way for me with Sprint, AT$T, and Verizon, notice I said smart/business phones as these devices are aimed at a different crowd of users). I could see where one might want the curve as just a phone (as it is a solid phone and now offers H@H), but honestly you lose about half of the great integration and functionality without a data plan on a BB. Although you could try to add through a third party dealer as they sdometimes don't have the data clause added on (when I went with AT$T, CompUSSR didn't add the data clause for their instant rebate and that is how I got around it). I went throught a third party for my T-MO curve and got it for $75 with instant rebates (not sure if the data claues was there as I want and use the data). Hope this helps some an good luck in getting what you want.