Jerusha: Abner, do you believe every word in the Bible literally?
Abner: Believe! The Bible is God's holy word written exactly as he commanded. I believe it all - in heaven and in hell and in original sin and in God's terrible, all-consuming wrath! If I did not believe, then I could not call myself a Christian!
J: Then I will no longer call myself a Christian. I don't believe in your God of wrath. I don't believe Keoki's in hell, either. I believe he has found God and Malama with him and Kelolo and all those who died there on the beach.
A: But it's impossible for the unbaptized to enter heaven...
J: Oh, Abner, I've never seen a people more generous, more loving, more filled with Christian charity than these! I will not believe that God has rejected them simply because they haven't been baptized. Not even that lost child whose birth you cursed.
A: These things are God's will, not mine. What else but God's wrath has the power to annihilate them?
J: Disease, despair - our lack of love. Our inability to find them beautiful. Our contempt for their ways, our lust for their land, our greed, our arrogance. That is what kills them, Abner. And that's what you must save them from.
A: They are already lost. I failed them. I failed these people and God. My ministry here is at an end.
J: Your ministry here is not ended. You will stay here in Lahaina and shelter and protect these people. You will win them to a merciful God with bonds of charity so strong, they will belong to him forever.
A: How?
J: By offering what you always valued most and found hardest to give, to them and to me. Your love.