i can see tanks point, but as for the difference between a blu ray version of black hawk down and the newest version on dvd which is remastered for high def playing on my upconverting dvd player through hdmi, theres a huge difference still. now im not saying every movie will look better than dvd counterpart by alot, but i ran both at the same time at same parts and just kept switching input on tv, and the difference is night and day for that movie. i dont really buy any movies other than ones that would look awesome in HD, like above mentions blackhawk down. rest of mine were bought cause they were 14 bucks for me once i mail in 10 dollar off rebates, so price wasnt the issue either, so thats my reasoning to getting them.