Yes, the base map would be closer requiring less trimming, but I can't see why it'd be more usable unless you abandoned AT altogether. The AT function trims very quickly. I saw meaningful trim values after only a short ride after first installing the AT kit, so I don't think trimming further from the base map is a real issue.
Well, first I don't see a reason to ever disconnect AT. If you create two base maps, one for cooling and another for mileage, and disconnect AT you will not have the functionality of AT to auto-tune on the fly. You'll basically have a PCV with no AT and two accurate base maps. This is a good setup, but you'd be losing the on-the-fly tunability of AT.
Instead, why not approach it like this: Use your rich map as the base, then apply your leaner target AFR's to achieve better mileage. The AT mode will be your default that you will run in most of the time. When the going gets hot, like stop-and-go summer traffic, switch to the rich base map. This way you still essentially have two maps to choose from, one of them being AT and the other the base map with no AT.
I will not "accept trims" after auto-tuning Jamie's target AFR's from his base map, as I wouldn't see running it except when oil temperature rises above acceptable limits. What I might do is "apply trims" and create a lean base map based on my tweaked target AFR's. I'm not sure when I would use it except if AT failed and I needed to go back the the PCV alone. The switch would still work to toggle between the two base maps.
This system auto-tunes much faster and with greater tolerances than the T'Max did, based on testimonials I've read from T'Max owners. T'Max apparently had a problem auto-tuning where the base map was very different from the targets, and that is why they recommended starting with a very close base map. The PCV-AT apparently doesn't have this limitation and can easily and quickly tune from a base map and target AFR's that are widely apart. Jamie even told me I wouldn't have any trouble using his old very rich map I originally got with his trick baffle kit sold before Jackpots came on the scene. I'll probably just use his newer map that came with the PCV.
Good idea, and I think 14.2:1 is a safe AFR that should bump mileage noticeably. I would guess you'd be in the lower- to mid-40's at 55mph with little or no stop-and-go.