Pixar - order of greatness

N

nauvashenron

New member
Best to worst...

Toy Story
Toy Story II
The Incredibles
Finding Nemo
Monsters Inc.
A Bug's Life

The first four are all superb, the last two pretty flawed.

Any other takers?
 
I would put them in this order -
Toy Story II
Finding Nemo
Monsters Inc
Toy Story
Incredibles
A Bugs Life

I love them all, Even A Bugs Life at the bottom of the list is one of my fave films.
 
I would say

Finding Nemo
Monsters Inc (to say this film is flawed is a cheek)
Toy story
Toy story II
Incredibles
A bugs life

Am still in shock that someone could think Monsters Inc is flawed.....how rude :o
 
None of them do anything for me, to be honest. I can't help thinking they should make a film that's not specifically aimed at children.
 
Think i'd go this order, but I love them all to be honest. :)

Toy story
Finding Nemo
Incredibles
Monsters Inc
Toy story II
A bugs life
 
If you think the Increadibles is aimed at children then you must have very mature children. Plus all of the films work at several levels, as do the competeion Shrek etc

My list

Toy Story2
Incredibles
Monsters Inc
Toy Story
Finding Nemo (too sugary for me)
Bugs Life
 
The Incredibles
Toy Story II
Toy Story
A Bug's Life
Monsters Inc
Finding Nemo

I think the Incredibles is a great film. That's not a great animated film, or children's film, just a great film. The makers have said that they don't make their films specifically for children btw.
 
Finding Nemo
*Ice Age*
Incredibles
Toy Story
Monsters Inc
Toy Story II
A Bugs Life

*is Ice Age a Pixar film, i thought it was but no one else has mentioned it.
 
Toy Story
Toy Story II
A Bug's Life
Monsters Inc.
Finding Nemo

I've always thought 'A Bug's Life' was really under-rated... and Finding Nemo extremely over-rated. I couldn't stand the cloying sentimentality of Finding Nemo... there was something extremely off about it.

(Still haven't got around to seeing 'The Incredibles'. :o )
 
Toy Story II
Toy Story
A Bug's Life
Finding Nemo
The Incredibles
Monsters, Inc

I've got all of them on DVD (Toy Story 1 & 2 indivdual DVRAB and The Ultimate Pixar Collection for the other 4 films), but it's the top three that I always go back to. Monsters, Inc just bored the crap out of me - the humour just wasn't up to the standard I had come to expect from Pixar, and The Incredibles tries too hard to impress people of all ages when the simplistic humour in Toy Story 1 & 2 (and the adult references slipped in) worked so much better.

Having said that, the extras DVD for The Incredibles is hilarious!
 
Back
Top