Out Of The Three Show Seth MacFarlane Is Known For...

Family Guy is the only one that I like. I never got into American Dad. I kinda view American Dad as Seth's Futurama. Also, I haven't gotten into the Cleveland Show. But I really haven't seen that much of it though.
 
I view it the same way, except I like it more than Family Guy.

Unlike most people, I actually liked the 1st episode and I was hooked to it. It was after it's first season that the show began to really shine, and I began to like Stan more than Peter. Aside from the despicable acts he does, at least he's not that big of a reatard like Peter.

Through Seasons 2-4, the show has good plots and writing for the characters. Season 5 is is having some misses, but I believe it will step up in quality
 
Pretty spot on. I laughed even with the sound off.

I will have to go with American Dad, despite Stan being a pretty mean guy, he still has managed to be much more likeable than the Peter from Season 5 and onward of Family Guy.

What I don't understand regarding that video is why Seth hasn't tried to make a new animated series not dealing with a family, I understand American Dad because back in 2003/2004, American Dad was supposed to be the "replacement" for Family Guy before FG was renewed in early 04.

But Seth seems like a pretty smart guy so I don't know why he hasn't tried stepping out of his formula yet, similar to how Groening tried making Futurama as different from The Simpsons as possible.
 
^- From what I remember he started a sitcom called The Winner but it was dropped after 2 or 3 episodes (I don't remember the exact number but it wasn't a lot).
 
Family Guy. Despite it's many flaws, it's still gut-bustingly hilarious.

American Dad is a close second, though. It can be hilarious while still having semblances of a plot, which is more than you can really say for Family Guy. I do agree that the show is starting to lose steam, though.

Cleveland...eh, not a huge fan, but it's not bad.
 
Probably American Dad. Though season 2 and 3 of Family Guy were really good, I find American Dad has been more consistent in the laughs department despite it's lame start.
 
I agree.

Family Guy is the only McFarlane show that I've been able to get into. I really don't watch Family Guy much anymore because it got more stupid and less funny. It still has its momemts but I haven't liked it that much since it got revived.
 
I chose Family Guy, even though it's not as good as it used to be it's still better than the other two by far.

American Dad is boring and overrated IMO.

The Cleveland Show has it's moments. Some episodes I've liked (the pilot and the one when Cleveland was rapping were awesome!!) and some were weak. It will get greenlit for at least another season, so I'm willing to give it time.
 
Interesting how although more people here voted for American Dad, Family Guy's talkback threads always get the most posts of any Sunday night FOX show.
 
To be fair, a lot of the posts in FG talkbacks are just play-by-play commentary from a relatively small amount of people posting multiple times before the half hour is up.
 
Family Guy is the most consistently funny of the three, American Dad is funny half of the time, and Cleveland is funny about 1/4 of the time.

The second half of Season 7 almost burnt me off the show for good, but the high quality of the episodes of this season hopefully means that episodes like "Family Gay" and "The Juice is Loose" were a belated and short-lived sophomore slump.
 
I chose that the two option, as I love both Family Guy and American Dad. Family Guy started off strong, and the first 3 seasons were awesome, then went on a slow decline til a truly terrible last season(though 420 was a very good ep). Thankfully, this year it seems as if McFarlane and the staff are actually trying to be actually funny and improve the episodes, and I have enjoyed every one this season. American Dad started off poor, but the fact that there is actually a plot is a plus, and it has just gotten better and better(the reverse of Family Guy). Best episode of Family Guy is the Stewie kills Lois/Lois kills Stewie 2 parter. Best American Dad episode is Tearjerker.
 
Back
Top