WARNING: Long ass post ahead.
OK, I see where both KBz and JLXC are coming from. But it's from almost two completely different sides of the ballpark. KB is talking about those in life that can but won't, and JL is talking about people that have a genuine setback and just flat out can't (except for the football argument).
I have my own sob story. It's not very glamorous but it's real. I grew up in small town USA. Where everyone knows everyone and everything you do. I went all the way through high school and did about a year and a half in college of psychology and was kicking ass in construction, before drugs overtook me. Before drugs overtook me for a time, I was one of the most respected members of the community. Our family wasn't the richest, but we were well enough to do.
My parents were widely respected people who were like the fighters of our community. And of course that respect naturally passed down to my generation of family by proxy. Then when my dad who adopted me passed away I used that as a sad tool to let myself go into a downward spiral into drugs. Then I got put in the slammer and got myself a felony. Now having a felony is a little bit of a chosen path (I don't believe those who can't see that), but we don't choose the path that follows.
Because of that happening (like I said... everyone knows everyone out here), I lost a ton of respect in the community. No one for a time would hire me. I tarnished the entire image of my family as well. My family had to fight for years to get out of the dark cloud that I had put them under from MY actions. No place would hire me for a time, and it GENUINELY fucking sucked. I thought I was never going to get a break. Eventually I went back into the construction field and began to just tough it out. The only really good thing I can say about the construction field is that they'll always hire you regardless of color, creed, sex, or criminal background, as long as you're a hard ass worker.
I went through the construction field and over time, I put all my legal troubles behind me (in a personal sense). I worked my way up to being a lead foreman and was very close to taking the tests to become a General Contractor. Over time I have regained the respect of the community around me, and have even been able to restore my family's name because of a few good natured things I've done (which is another story for another time). I met the woman of my dreams and I was happily wed on July 12th, 2006. However, with things going good... some bad has to sometimes go with it. A few weeks after I got married, I suffered a torn ACL (in my knee for those not in the know). It was bad enough to where I actually had to be put on the shelf for the first time in my life. It didn't happen at work so I had to go through applying for medi-cal and putting up with all the red tape bullshit. And by the time the doctors were finally able to get to it. I can no longer re-enter the construction field.
For a time I didn't know what I was gonna do. I now had no income, a fucked up knee, and a wife and child to support. Me and my wife had to wind up going into separate residences just so she could continue living in a house (which no matter what bullshit I tell people, that is VERY hard to deal with). However, as you've noticed... I'm not the kind of person to just lay down and take it. So, this fall I finally re-enrolled in college. Surprisingly my past professors kept my credits on board and didn't vanquish them away. I've took on some other classes and I am looking forward to a future as a teacher or psychologist. I still have to deal with employers who cast a blind eye upon me once they see that I'm a felon, but I know something is going to break sooner or later, and I'll be working hard once again... only in a different field of employment.
I've gone through many ups and downs, but unlike those which JL described as genuinely having a setback... I know that I'm still in a position that I CAN make things happen. I'm not the kind of person who can rest on my laurels as I've seen many others do. So in a way, I agree with both your points of view. It's just that I've lived the version that KB has described and I didn't like it. But KB, I take it that you're the type that hasn't let life beat you with a wet noodle for too long either. Well my hat goes off to you, but you have to realize that we ARE the minority in life. There are too many that don't get educated or street-smart enough to bring themselves out of the dregs... even as hard as they may try.
That's all I'm going to say for now.