considering the content of the book, and the time they had for the film, i think it was brilliant. The director decided to change the idea from 2 films released a few months apart to the one, which maybe wasnt the best idea, but still it was brilliant, i think emma watson and daniel radcliff where great and the one who plays ron was ok, dont really like his character, where was snape in this film?! also mad eye was great, was very funny, all in all i will be going back to watch this film!