Music Banter Hall Of Fame: Nominations Thread

What I hate is that they're going to do better then ATDI, when ATDi are so much better in my eyes. I'm very torn on this anyway, because I think they're okay, but they're music definatley gets tiresome.
 
Of course they are through and not just because they are 'different'. to keep your identity secret for 30 odd years and still crank out some of the most brain warping music out there?

In for sure. You don't have to like them but damn they are original.
 
Well they are a important and highly influential band in British music. But I guess the hall of fame is about whether you like a band or not. I thought musical importance had some role in it as well, guess not.
 
None of those people are ahead of Tom Waits for me in terms of how I feel about them, but what does the order in which the people are nominated matter? It's not as if the people you mention have been rejected. Their cases just haven't been reviewed yet.
 
You should add a "I don't know" option for those who don't want to vote but still want to be able to see the results without clicking on the "View Poll Results" link.
 
I am not a fan of teh prog, but as Piss Me Off pointed out when Elliott Smith was up for nomination, it would be crazy to see a rab Hall Of Fame without them. At least I dig In The Court Of The Crimson King, so it's a yes from me.
 
I appreciate your approach and you being upfront about it.

I am still undecided, but will likely end up going yes.

Pet SounRAB is a tad overrated I suppose, though it's still listenable at worst. I can understand calling it inconsistent or boring, but not bad.

Smiley Smile is also pretty good and their albums consistently contained a hit single for whatever that's worth.

Hmmmm...
 
Back
Top