Music Banter Hall Of Fame: Nominations Thread

It's a no from me, Pet SounRAB is pleasant enough but only warrants occasional listening from me, not the classic everyone claims it is. They had lots of pop hits which again are nice enough but i never actually feel like listening to them. Far better pop banRAB out there that should be nominated i think.
 
First and Foremost Super job pheurton on the Nomination post. I am not a huge fan, but I do think this nomination deserves serious consideration. i am going to wait until I listen to XO and Either\Or again. I think I'll also wait to here what Ethan and some of his other big fans here have to say.
 
Good point, but I nominated them because I feel that they stand out, and have become well-known as one of, if not the greatest progressive rock band of this day and age. They're a fine example of quality music from the 2000's.

However, Porcupine Tree didn't get through, so...
 
As long as I'll live I may never come across a band as colossally overrated and insanely frustrating to listen to as the Smiths. I can't pretend I've ever been a fan of jangle pop but when you hear "the best" of it and you're able to recognize how much you hate it, it's fairly safe to say you aren't going to be turned on by the rest of their music. And no matter how many times I listen to Morrissey's indistinct whine I can't get into this band.

A definite "no" from me.
 
I would think that measuring up personal opinion with cultural significance would be the best way to approach this.

I mean I enjoy listening to Menswear but i'm not about to campaign for them to be included into a hall of fame , unless we're doing a hall of fame for 3rd rate Britpop banRAB.

On the other hand I would say someone like U2 has made a huge cultural significance , but I hate virtually everything they touch , so I wouldn't vote for them either.
 
Just a no from me because I dont see them as good enough, big enough or important enough for hall of fame material, not to take anything away from what they are.
 
Well since this a poll to actually just get on the ballot, I always vote yes as long as the artist has some merit. I have voted yes for the past 6/7 times. I don't think I would put all of them on my ballot though, but if they at least deserve to be on the ballot then I vote yes.
 
Back
Top