RX-8 for sure. The 3 is nice, but its bigger and front wheel drive. If you have to haul a lot of crap the 3 would def be a good car, but if you don't, the RX-8 is sweet. I scond boneheads demands for you to get a manual. The Mazdaspeed 3 will only be available in manual, but the RX-8 can come with an auto. Don't make that choice, manual is the only way to go.