What kind of rpg's do you like? I take it that you like BK1 more because of the Cell Shading. Or you prefer BK2 because it is more real? I've heard that the music isn't so great. The game snap shots do justice that BK1 is probably the most beautiful game out for the GC. But how's the game play? Is it free roaming or is it on set paths? Is it more of an action RPG, a stragedy RPG, a fighting RPG (ala Tekken), or an FF RPG (about a 45 degree Diablo game). How far back is the camera?
Anyway, I can't rent these 2 games, I've read a lot of reviews, and BK1 isn't too bad at $18, used, or $20, new.