Immanuel Kant: How did he reconcile Rationalism and Empiricism? Can anyone...

  • Thread starter Thread starter mitya51
  • Start date Start date
M

mitya51

Guest
...discuss his philosophy? Or maybe discuss his place in philosophy from Hume's Skepticism to Idealism. Basically is it Kant showed how knowledge is possible apart from experience (empiricism)? any random thoughts are welcome as well. Feel free to pontificate about your knowledge of Kant. (isn't that what answers.y is about?
 
Though Kant is sometimes credited with uniting the warring empiricist and rationalist movements of his time, it might be most accurate to say that he united them by arguing that they were both completely wrong.

His reasoning was something like this: Nobody's senses and thoughts are completely free to do anything - they operate on limits. Thus, neither senses alone nor thoughts alone can ever directly exceed these limits and see the world in itself.

Instead, he argued, the two disciplines needed to work together. Rationalists cannot reasonably deny the entire world of the senses - senses are all we have to know anything but our own minds. Thus any rationalist idea which involved anything other than the mind of the person doing the thinking cannot possibly be correct without a bit of empiricism mixed in with it.

Likewise, there are things empiricists must know in order to operate empirically. A rational knowledge of their senses' limitations CAN help them step outside those limitations. Knowledge of history, memory, prediction, and theory keep us from the need to constantly repeat experiments to prove over and over that something is still true if it was true ten seconds ago. Morality and free will are intuitively apparent, yet completely outside of the empirical realm.

All of which are good arguments. So good, in fact, that both groups decided to play nice for a while. I love it when there's a happy ending.
 
Now now for the lighter side....We all know mmanuel Kant. But what if he could?
 
I am an Objectivist, and rather than go over all that Objectivists hate about Kant's mysticism, I will simply refer you to this link.
http://www.aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/kant.html

It is interesting to note that Ayn Rand who formulated and named "Objectivism," also "reconciled" Rationalism and Empiricism but completely tore Kant a new "hole" by demonstrating how irrational his approach was. What Kant accepted of those two schools, Rand threw much out the window. On the other hand, for many of the things that Kant threw out the window, Rand had some acceptance.
 
Back
Top