If anyone know anything about military recruitment please help me?

babybug01

New member
Im doing a speech about how i think the marine recruiting age should be lower. I need to have 3 main points and i already have 2: recruiters have a quota they have to meet and the mental problem most soldiers have when they come home. I cant think of a 3rd main point...can you help me think of a 3rd one
i didn't mean recruitment age should be lower...im doing my speech about how the age should be rised...above 18
 
Not to make your speech harder but I don't think your 2 points really work in this situation. You're saying you want the Marines to be able to recruit people under the age of 17/18? What about their ability to finish high school? Marine recruiters don't seem to be having any trouble meeting their quotas right now so the age change wouldn't really do much. As for PTSD, how would having even younger kids go help with that? They'd be even less able to deal with the trauma because they'd still be going through puberty and other such emotional issues. I can't honestly think of any reason to lower the age more than it is.

ETA: Okay but your points still don't make a lot of sense if the age was raised above 18. For one, how would that help recruiters reach their quota because raising it above 18 would cause them to lose all those candidates who they're getting between 18-21 (I guess I'm assuming you mean raise it to 21 because otherwise it's not a significant enough of a raise to mean anything). As for mental issues, it really doesn't have a lot to do with age at 18-21. Sure younger people may be less emotionally equipped to handle some of the stressors the military can give you. However, Marines/Soldiers/Sailors/Airmen of all ages can get PTSD. It depends entirely on their experiences and their own ability to deal with those experiences and I know of men/women in their 30s and 40s who have just as hard a time dealing with death and trauma that war will bring as those in their teens and 20s. Honestly I think the age is fine as is. Sorry since that doesn't do anything for your speech but there are a lot of 18 year olds who have really benefited from military service and I feel they are old enough to choose to join.
 
Not trying to be mean or disparaging here but there really isn't One good reason to lower the age of recruitment for the Marines or anyone else for that matter. What would you like to lower it to past the age of 17 in some instances? There would be way too much controversy if anyone in the Federal Government even thought about doing this. It is eighteen for a reason and there really are no good reasons to lower it anymore than it is. When people start seeing their 15 and 16 year old sons and daughters coming home in body bags, well you can imagine what would happen. The Marines are doing just fine meeting recruiting goals and yes, some are coming back with PTSD but that is no reason to lower the age. I think the reason why you or I cannot think of a third reason is because there isn't "one good" reason to even contemplate this in the first place and as an argumentative essay it would be very very weak at best. ( You're probably going to flip out your teacher too if you give a speech like this :) )
 
Back
Top