Where was this? Hmmm... a likely story.
I just googled that (google is a good friend today) and ended up with pictures of Amy Lee without makeup on (not porno, for god's sake, I know you were thinking that). Without the makeup she looks just like a girl who invited herself back to my house once at uni - no joke, she just followed me home and then insisted on staying the night in my housemate's room while he slept on the sofa. Weirdo.
Maybe it was the same girl, with a Fred Durst lookalike.