How has random breathalyzer testing worked for Austrailia?

K

Kevin

New member
This is being proposed in Canada now and they point to Ireland and Australia as their proof that it works to reduce deaths. MADD says that Australia had "36% fewer deaths" once this was implemented.
What was the system in place before this was implemented?

Honestly I don't see how this random breathalyser testing will reduce deaths as the current system is very good. The police have "RIDE" checkpoints and stick their head in every vehicle and if they smell alcohol or see any indication of alcohol consumption they then have the right to give you a breathalyser test. It's currently an offence to refuse.

I'm neither for nor against this but right now I'm feeling that this is just good optics from the current government.
 
As an Australian, I have never known another system. They are very aggressive about it here and wont let you escape. Units will give chase if you turn down a side-street before the RBT station. Also, we have random drug testing here too, in the RBT units, to catch ANYONE driving under the influence of ANYTHING.
It is aggressive, but I'm not sure of the stats re: deaths since RBT's were introduced. I would personally like the police to be as vigilant as possible and stop people from potentially killing my whole family in an accident. The sad part is, drunk people usually survive because they are more relaxed upon impact, and it's the innocent who die.
In the end, people need to take responsibility when they are driving, and if they don't it is up to our law enforcement to do something about it, I guess. I am comfortable with the current system, but would be wary of any further control given to the police.
The question I would ask: is it necessary? Is there a problem with the current system, or are they trying to fix something that doesn't need fixing? I think it is a good system to trial if there are problems, but you know what they say about when it aint broke...
PS Redstar, where are you in Australia? It's .05 where I am...
 
Yes, it works like a dream here in Australia, and roadside drug testing is also proving successful.It has not deterred the drunks or druggies,they are still managing to kill people here.
I have seen the American balance testing, and i think some could still slip through the net with that.
If you refuse a roadside test here in Australia, you are locked up regardless, and an automatic licence disqualification.Our alcohol limit here is point 03.
 
Back
Top